Editor’s note: This is a guest post by Tonia Christle from Tonia Says on IEPs (Individualized Education Plan). I asked her to write about IEPs from the perspective of an adult with a disability who grew up having IEPs.
Imagine that you have just started your first job. You’ve been there a month, and now it is time for your performance review. It’s not the best fit job-wise. You are expected to type more than 200 words a minute, with no mistakes. You are expected to be fluent in a language you have heard spoken, but do not understand and cannot speak yourself. You really need the money, though, so you cope. You make it work. You imagine the review will be unpleasant but as you have never had one before, you really have no idea what to expect.
You arrive in the room for your review, only to discover it’s not just your boss who is going to review you, it’s also her boss, and the boss of that other department who hates you. All the bosses in your entire company are there…and also your parents…because their input matters, too.
They are all Team Members and you are the Learner.
It is the worst performance review ever:
- You don’t ask for help (because you have been raised to be self-sufficient.)
- You accept help you don’t need to save time.
- You take too long moving between tasks, even though you are moving as fast as you can.
- You start tasks too early.
- You need prompting through unfamiliar processes and into chaotic team building activities that feel delicate at best, and unsafe, at worst.
All these department heads have been watching you while you were unaware. They have been evaluating you. They have been timing you in tasks you didn’t realize had a time limit.
They ask for your feedback: This is a good goal for you, don’t you think? To refuse help you don’t need based on your boss’s judgement, not your own?
You nod, because these are all your superiors, and you have no real power here.
You leave demoralized, knowing you will have to come back again and again (twice a year for nearly a decade.)
You are nine years old.
As an adult, the job performance review metaphor is the closest example I have to convey just how uncomfortable being present at my own IEP meetings was as a child. While I definitely agree with my mom that it was important that I was involved in my own education, I have some additional suggestions for parents to think about before including your child or children for the bulk of their IEP meetings.
CONSIDER YOUR CHILD’S AGE:
I’ve read many accounts of parents of kids with disabilities about just how difficult IEP season is. It’s a time when you are face to face with all of the ways your child is behind other children their age, all the ways they need help, or maybe all the things that are not in place yet for your child that should be. If it is that difficult for you, please consider the impact it may have on your nine-year-old, your ten-year-old, or even, your thirteen-year-old. Know that we are already, always, painfully aware of the areas in which we fall short. To sit in on a meeting dedicated to pointing out those things is unnecessary, at best, until we are mature enough to understand that the meeting is for our benefit.
Mary Evelyn Smith, who blogs at What Do You Do, Dear? suggests waiting until waiting until your child is in high school to be present at their IEP meetings (and depending on the child, perhaps, even that is too early.) I tend to agree with her.
By the time I was in high school, IEP meetings were far less difficult for me, and I had a better grasp of what they were and that I was not in trouble, for the duration.
ALTERNATIVE WAYS TO INCLUDE A CHILD:
That being said, I absolutely agree with my mom that my involvement and presence at IEP meetings was necessary. Here are some alternative ways to include your younger child, prior to (or instead of) actually being present at their own meeting:
Have your child present for a few minutes for a brief (positive) overview of their progress:
Jess Wilson, who blogs at a diary of a mom, once detailed how her thirteen-year-old daughter was present for just a few minutes at the start of every IEP meeting. During this time, her daughter was able to hear positive remarks from her teachers and others involved in her education. She was not only able to see all the members of her “team” but know that she herself was an integral member of that team.
I think this is a great idea and something that would allow a child to be involved in a meeting of this type without the emotional damage of being present while only the child’s areas of difficulty are discussed.
Have your child answer some questions prior to the IEP meeting, when they are comfortable, and present their responses (with permission) at the meeting:
I have seen questionnaires intended for parents at IEP time. It’s often stated at the top of these forms that “your input is needed” and it absolutely is. However, I would also suggest something similar for your child.
When you are at home and your child is comfortable, ask them some questions about school. Explain this is because you are going to talk to their teachers to figure out all the ways to make school a good place for them. When you are done asking your child questions, be sure to ask if they will let you share what they said with their teachers, so the teachers know important things about your child.
Here are some sample questions you can ask your child (feel free to adapt according to child’s understanding):
What are you good at?
What do you need help with?
What do you most like to do at home?
What is easy in school?
What is hard in school?
How do people treat you in school?
How do you want people to treat you in school?
HOW TO COPE IF THERE IS NO OTHER CHOICE BUT TO BRING YOUR CHILD TO THEIR IEP:
Even the best laid plans are at risk of falling apart at the last minute. So if you can’t find a babysitter or if your childcare falls through at the last minute, here is one suggestion to help your child cope at their own IEP:
Headphones and a movie:
Giving your child crayons and paper, or a book to read is not going to be enough of a barrier from all of the words they will hear about themselves. In the instance that their presence at their own meeting cannot be avoided, bring headphones and your personal gadget of choice with their favorite TV show or movie.
This will provide not only visual distraction but auditory as well, so your child does not have to hear everything that is being said about them. If you do not have access to a media-playing gadget, a favorite music playlist (or dust off your old Discman and make a mix C.D.) can suffice when paired with another quiet visual activity.
Your child is the heart of the IEP team. Involve them, but also protect them. That way, when the time comes, and they are old enough, they can confidently be a part of this process, working alongside you, to let you know what is best for them.
Special Needs Parents, Are You Surviving?
I created a guide with 13 practical ways to help you find peace in the midst of chaos, opt in to make sure you get a copy of this freebie!
I was never allowed in my own IEP meetings and personally I felt insulted that the schools did not involve me in the process. It’s my body and my education. My family asked to have me included and we were denied. So no I do NOT like the “protect” them idea. If I had not been “protected” I would not have failed math exams for years due to inaccessibility and would have been less overwhelmed by the access meetings I had by myself in college. Involvement is empowering even if you do not like what you hear. Unless the kid is say under 8. Then I agree.
Maybe it depends on the child. I know my daughter hated the one she attended and came home feeling very discouraged and she asked us why there was a room full of people focused on all the things she cannot do as well. So maybe it depends on the child or the situation. Maybe in the future she will want to be present, but as her mom, I can do the battle for her and make sure the school is doing what they need to do. It sounds to me that your parents had to deal with a difficult school who was not doing their job at providing your supports.
And yay, you were able to leave a comment, I hope the issue you were having before is resolved, did you have to clear the cache or cookies?
Yeah I updated my browser and cleared stuff out. Hope it keeps working. Of course it depends on the child! It also might depend on the disability. If your sweet daughter is not comfortable then by all means don’t force her!!! I just don’t want some parents reading this to overly shelter their kid like this one girl I knew with a neurologic disability who was so sheltered about her disability that when she left her sheltered environment she had a lot of self esteem issues and panic attacks. She and some disabled college students I know told me that if they had been going to IEP meetings by at least 12 they would have had an easier time. I also noticed that IEP meetings are extremely focused on negatives which I think is really,really bad for the student. In my college it is the complete opposite. They tell the disabled students and even disabled professors what they do right and then the disabled person chooses the accommodations they want,rather than being coached into something they don’t need. What Tonia and you and your daughters go through seems to be something based on a false idea of what “ideal” functioning should be and seems manipulative. As you might have noticed with your daughters when you are born with a disability we want to function with as much ease as we can but what makes things easy for us often does not involve the able bodied person’s “ideal”. Yes, my situation with IEPs was horrible so I switched to home school for middle school and high school and I thank God every single day for my home school years! Best decision we made for my academics personally! Just follow your instincts Ellen. I think you are doing the right thing for your girls!
Hi again Ellen, not sure if my last reply went through so I just wanted to say again YES I AGREE IT DOES INDEED DEPEND ON THE CHILD! I wish IEPs for kids were handled the way my college handles accessibility where they focus on what the student or even professor CAN do and just lets them know what help is available if they ever do need it.
Yes I cleared my cookies and tried to fix my browser. Hope it works.